Cook: Dem House Victory "Within Reach"

That's the title of Charlie Cook's latest take on the outlook for the midterms (via the Stakeholder, which highlights an excellent example of how the CW has changed from a year ago). Cook argues that if the election were held today, whether or not the Democrats would win a majority in the House would be virtually within the margin of error:

The current model predicts a net Democratic gain of 10 seats. When we factor in a four-seat margin of error, the model projects that as of today, under current conditions, and without speculating about what the national political environment may do between now and November, Democrats will make a net gain of six to 14 seats. With a bit of luck -- or a wave of any size -- Democrats might even grasp their gold ring: 15 seats.

The question is whether the national environment becomes more or less favorable for Republicans in the next nine months. And, according to Cook, writing about Boehner's election in a separate article, the coming months aren't looking good:

Even a brief glance at the polls shows that congressional Republicans lag far below the approval numbers of even a president who is in a slump....

The abuses by the Democratic House majorities of the early 1990s now pale in comparison. Boehner seems to understand that his election gives House Republicans one last chance.

The question is whether he and his colleagues take it.

With the Abramoff and Fitzgerald vultures circling, and Bush's ratings still in the tank, the GOP is being forced to fall back on keeping retirements to a minimum and hoping their cash advantage will pay off:

In the past few campaign cycles, the NRCC had enough money to go on the attack very early and very effectively. The danger for Republicans this time is that while the committee has much more money than the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee -- $19 million at the end of 2005, compared with $15.7 million for the Democrats -- the GOP's resources might not be sufficient to douse all the anti-Republican fires that could erupt around the nation.

I like the wildfire metaphor. It turns out we may not need a "wave," but just a small breeze to fan the flames. And the more seats the we challenge, the drier the ground will be.



Display:


We need to work harder... (none / 0)

Sorry to be a pain about this but I sense a feeling of complacency that I fear may lull potential party activists into non-action.  I find many people who just assume we will have a good time of it this election.

That is simply not true.  Viewed historically our polling numbers are frighteningly bad.  The mid-term elections for the party of incumbent President in his second term should be a disaster for them.  By historically precedent the Republicans should be polling MUCH worse.

The sad fact is that now, 9 months out, polls point to the possibility of some mild pickups by us while leaving the senate in the hands of the Republicans.  This at a time where the party not controlling the White House should have HUGE leads in the polls.

The Republicans haven't even started to fight back yet.  And don't allow your hatred of Rove, et al to blind you to the fact that these people are plain ol' outstanding at getting their vote out and electing their candidates.

We need to work and fight every day until election day without ever assuming anything.


by Bridget Dwyer on Tue Feb 07, 2006 at 01:15:00 PM EST

Cook Can Say All He Wants... (none / 0)

Bridget is right. We cannot rest on theoretical laurels here.

The facts are that most local Democratic parties are completely unprepared for 2006. Unless these important political entities are beefed up before election day, then I believe our victory will be stunted - rather than maximized.

We don't just need to get back Congress (although that's our number 1 priority) but we also need to be looking down the ballot. State legislatures, governorships, and local offices need to be focused on as well.


"The collapse of confidence in the Republican leadership is not enough to elect Democratic leadership." -Dean
by gatordemocrat on Tue Feb 07, 2006 at 03:15:39 PM EST
[ Parent ]

I Don't See Anyone Acting Complacent (3.00 / 1)

I see people getting confident that hard work can bring us victory.  That's precisely the mindset we want to have.

The sad fact is that now, 9 months out, polls point to the possibility of some mild pickups by us while leaving the senate in the hands of the Republicans.  This at a time where the party not controlling the White House should have HUGE leads in the polls.

What do you base this on?  Second term mid-term elections don't grow on trees, and tend to differ significantly from one another.  When was the last time the GOP held both houses in the midterm of a second-term GOP President?  Let me give you a hint: Gallup hadn't started polling yet.

The opposition's 2nd mid-term pickup tends to result from re-election landslides that bring the incumbants party into power in marginal seats they otherwise can't hold.  So the subsequent losses are due to turnout effects more than popularity/approval effects. But this is simply a tendency, and there's a great deal of variation in the record.  The last two examples saw the Dems pick up 5 seats both in opposition (Reagan) and in office (Clinton), for example.

I still say we have a shot at a realigning election, meaning more than just barely taking back the House.  But November is a long, long way off.  And I'm not taking anything for granted.


by Paul Rosenberg on Tue Feb 07, 2006 at 04:20:50 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Exactly (none / 0)

This news should encourage us to redouble our efforts, not grow complacent. If the breeze turns into a gale, or if it starts blowing the other way, either way, we need to be ready.


by tparty on Tue Feb 07, 2006 at 04:31:39 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: We need to work harder... (none / 0)

Right now we are too pessimistic.  Anne Wolfe in NJ decided not to challenge again in a seat where the incumbent R got 57% because her contributors told her her candidacy was not viable.

Nothing is guaranteed but this is, at a minimum, our best chance in over 30 years to pick up seats.  That is something to get excited about!

Complacent?  No.  Optimistic and excited, yes!


by David Kowalski on Tue Feb 07, 2006 at 06:40:10 PM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.